St. Louis Browns outfielder Milt Byrnes was born on November 15, 1910 in St. Louis Missouri. Byrnes is a true St. Louis, home grown baseball player. He grew up playing baseball at Fairgrounds Park, played American Legion baseball for St. Louis Post #4, and was a standout in the Muny League across the city. He was scouted by both Charlie Barrett of the Cardinals and Ray Cahill of the Browns.
The Browns would sign Byrnes out of high school, and Byrnes would enjoy a 16-year baseball career. Milt Byrnes would spend his first seven years within the Browns minor leagues affiliates. He would quickly move through the organization, playing for the Lafayette White Sox, Palestine Pals, and San Antonio Missions in 1936. He would spend four seasons with the Missions (1936-39), before playing for the Toledo Mud Hens (1940-42).
As World War II continued to develop, many of the Browns players were drafted into service. They lost two of their coveted outfielders, Walt Judnich and Glenn McQuillen, to the war effort and Milt Byrnes was brought up to fill their roster spots. Browns manager Luke Sewell was not a fan of "replacement players" during the war, and seemed to down play the impact that Byrnes had on the team. Byrnes suffered from chronic asthma which led to a '4F' rating with the military, but his asthma never impaired his ability on the field. Milt Byrnes could actually be considered the best "replacement player" in baseball during the war.
From 1943-45, Byrnes played in 390 games with the Browns. He recorded 350 hits, including 77 doubles, 15 triples, 16 home runs and 154 RBIs. His .274 batting average, .768 OPS, and 118 OPS+ was among the team leaders of the era. Byrnes led American League oufielders .997 fielding percentage in 1943. His .396 OBP in 1944 would be the fifth best in the American League. He would also finish in the top 10 in walks in both 1944-45. The impct of Milt Byrnes can easily be seen in his 7.2 WAR over his these three seasons with the Browns. Only Vern Stephens' 14.6 WAR was better, and Browns slugging first baseman , George McQuinn registered a 4.8 War.
Unfortunately, a late season slump would keep Byrnes out of the 1944 World Series. Sewell decided to platoon four outfielders over Byrnes in the series, after he hit just .241 in the month of September. Byrnes would go hitless in the series as a pinch hitter.
Byrnes would often be compared to another great St. Louis outfielder, Jack Tobin of the 1920s Browns teams. Both were great contact hitters, drag bunters, fast runners, and elite fielders.
With the conclusion of World War II, the Browns crowded outfield led to Milt Brynes being traded to the New York Yankees on April 2, 1946. Brynes would get lost in the Yankees organization and never play in the Major Leagues again. He spent the next six years, playing with nine different minor league teams. Though minor league statistics are often incomplete, Milt Byrnes never batted below .250 in a season and had 694 recorded hits in 833 minor league games from 1946-51.
Milt Byrnes would continue to live in St. Louis after his playing days were over. He quietly raised a family and worked in sales at a bottling company. He may be one of the most overlooked stars in team history, but Milt Byrnes made the most of his opportunity to play with the St. Louis Browns.