St. Louis Browns pitcher John Terry was born on November 4, 1877 in Fairfax, Iowa. The astounding story of John Baxter Terry is both incomplete and uncredited. For over 100 years, he was a player that was not recognized by baseball historians and journals. His career has more questions than answers, and more holes than solid facts. That is what makes John Terry such a mystery.
What is known of John Terry is that he was pitcher for the Browns during the 1903 season. It is not documented is he was a right-handed pitcher or "lefty". He is the only MLB player to come from Fairfax, Iowa, which is a suburb of Cedar Rapids. He was a highly touted prospect when he attended Washington High School. His family moved to St. Louis after he graduated, and he went to work for the phone company. There are no transactions recorded of John Terry signing any contract with a minor league or major league team. It is believed that he played for company and semipro teams after moving to the "Gateway City".
On September 17, 1902, at the age of 24, John Terry pitched a complete game for the Detroit Tigers against the St. Louis Browns. It was not uncommon for traveling teams to sign one-day contracts to local players while visiting other cities. The Tigers were in the middle of brutal road trip, playing 20 games in 10 days, and disparately needed pitching help. Terry made his MLB debut with Detroit, pitching a complete game in the 3-1 loss to the Browns, recording two earned runs on eight hits and one walk. Terry was released after the game.
The Browns would given Terry a second chance in the majors the following season. Without any contract records available, John Terry would appear in three games for the Browns in July of 1903. The Browns would play 24 of 27 games on the road over a stretch of three weeks, and brought the 25-year old pitcher along for the trip. John Terry would pitch the final three innings in a 6-8 loss to the Boston Americans in "Bean Town" on July 6. He would make his second appearance in Washington, allowing one run while scattering four hits over five innings, in a 4-3 Browns win. John Terry would earn his only MLB win on July 31, as he hurled a complete game 10-3 victory over the Tigers in Detroit.
His final stats after this month included giving up 21 hits, four walks, and five earned runs, while striking out two on the way to a 2.55 ERA and a 1-1 record. He did hit one batter in each game. There is no record of Terry pitching at any level after these games.
The incredible part of John Terry's story is that he was never given credit for these appearances during his lifetime. The Baseball Encyclopedia was established in 1922 and documented all aspects (games, players, etc.) of baseball history. John Baxter Terry never appeared in these records, because he was mistakenly identified as John Burchard Terry. This error lasted until 2010, when SABR identified the mistake and corrected the name change, giving the correct John Terry the credit he deserved. Terry passed in 1958, so he never saw the correction made by the baseball "experts".
This does not seem to stop John Baxter Terry from living an incredible life. He settle down in Cedar Rapids where he established the "JB Terry Electrical Supply Company". According to his obituary (January 10, 1958), he served as the President of the Chamber of Commerce and the Cedar Rapids Country Club. He also served his community as a member of the Elks Club and El Kasir Shrine. The strange story of John Terry is another example of a Browns player who was given an opportunity to live out his baseball dream, before making a lasting impact within his community.