St. Louis Browns pinch hitter and right fielder, Earl Pruess, was born on April 2, 1895 in Chicago, Illinois. There is little known about the life and career of Pruess, except that he lived his entire MLB dream in just two-plus innings on September 15, 1920. He would play along side some of the greatest names in franchise history, including Georg Sisler, Baby Doll Jacobson, and Hank Severeid.
Pruess was 25 years old when he began playing professional baseball with the Cedar Rapids Rabbits. There is no record of him playing high school, college, or semipro baseball, but it is assumed that he played some form of baseball before joining the Rabbits. He would record 33 hits in 55 games for Cedar Rapids, including seven doubles, three triples, a home run, and a .186 average.
There is no apparent reason for the Browns to welcome up Earl Pruess for a late season game, but he would make his MLB debut on September 15, against the Boston Red Sox. The Browns would be up 15-3, when Puess would pinch hit for Browns right fielder Jack Tobin. Tobin had already gone 3-for-4 with a double and three runs scored, when Pruess entered the game in the seventh inning. With one out and Browns' LF Lyman Lamb on first base, Earl Pruess earned a walk off Boston's Waite Hoyt. He would steal second base, and reach third on a ground ball out by Carl Weilman. Earl Pruess would score as the next batter, SS Wally Gerber ripped a single to center field. He would stay in the game and catch a fly ball from Boston's Ossie Vitt in the eighth inning, and Mike McNally in the nineth inning. Earl Pruess' final MLB statistics would include one plate appearance, one walk, one steal, one run scored, and two putouts in the field. With these stats, Pruess faded into the rests of his adult life. There is no record of him playing organized baseball after his single MLB game.
It could easily be assumed that he participated in other semipro or recreational leagues, but that is not the rest of his story. Earl Pruess would settle down in the small town of Itasca, Illinois, where he served as the town trustee. He would also become a boxing champion, and one of the top bowlers of his era.
The St. Louis Browns have plenty of players that had brief careers in the Majors. Earl Pruess could be the best example of the Browns' "Moonlight Graham" in their history. A player who only had a small taste of the big leagues, but made the most of that opportunity. Players like Pruess are just as important to the history of the Browns as the all-stars and legends.