St. Louis Browns RHP Bill Trotter was born on August 10, 1908 in Cisne, Illinois. Trotter would be the only MLB player to be from Cisne, which is about 120 miles east of St. Louis. He would enjoy a 17-year career in baseball, with a majority of it as a member of the Browns.
Bill Trotter began his career at the age of 20 when he signed in with the Scottsdale Scotties of the MidAtlantic League in 1929. He would go on to play for the Waynesboro Red Birds (1929-30), and the Terre Haute Tots (1932). There were two years where he appears to have taken some time away from baseball (1931 and 1933) for undisclosed reasons.
The Pittsburgh Pirates organization signed him before the 1934 season and sent him to the Springfield Pirates (1934) and then the Portsmith Pirates (1935-36) before releasing him.
The Browns signed free agent Bill Trotter on April 21, 1937. From the moment he was signed, Trotter became a key figure on the Browns pitching staff. In four of his six years with the Browns, he would appear in more than 29 games. In 1938, he would only appear in one game with St. Louis, after going 22-9 with a 3.40 ERA over 249 innings in 39 games with the San Antonio Missions. From 1939-41, Bill Trotter would be used out of the bull pen, averaging 107 strikeouts in 101 innings in 35 appearances. In his time with the Browns, he would tally a 19-32 record with 30 games started, 69 games finished, in 436.2 innings. His best game could have been on April 23, 1940, when he entered the game in the second inning for starting pitcher Emil Bildilli, and shut down the New York Yankees. He would scatter nine hits and two runs over the final eight innings while gaining the win.
Because of his role on the staff, his pitching would rarely make many headline. Trotter did lead the American League in hit batters in 1937.
After a slow start to the 1942 season, he would be involved in a trade between the Browns and the Washington Nationals. The Browns would send Trotter and catcher Roy Cullenbine to Washington for RF Mike Chartak and RHP Steve Sundra. After a season in Washington, Trotter would return to St. Louis as a member of the Cardinals organization, where he split time between the Red Birds and the Rochester Red Wings (1943-45).
Bill Trotter would spend his final years in the minor leagues, playing for the Milwaukee Brewers (1946), Little Rock Travelers (1946), Annison Rams (1946) and the Beaumont Explorers (1947).
Bill Trotter would retire from baseball and settle down in Arlington, Massachusetts. He would work for the Caterpillar Tractor Company, and tell long stories of his time in baseball. It has been written that his favorite story was of the Yankees game in 1940.